Guide
Cold e-mail or direct mail to local businesses: the 2026 numbers
What the 2025-2026 benchmarks say about cold e-mail replies, what the rules ask of a sender, what a postcard costs to mail, and how many local listings have an e-mail address at all.
Every count of listings in this guide is read from the data when the page is made: release 2026-10-21.0, counted on . How they were counted
In the 2025 data of two cold e-mail platforms, the average reply rate was 3.43 percent of e-mails sent (Instantly) and 4.5 percent of the people written to (Hunter). A postcard costs $0.65 to mail at the single-piece price. And in the open data this site counts, 35% of local business listings in the United States have an e-mail address on record, against 80% with a website. Which way to reach a local business depends on the share with an e-mail address as well as on the reply rates.
If you sell to local businesses, plumbers, restaurants, dental offices, salons, you can reach a new one by e-mail or by post. This guide keeps to the numbers that can be checked: the benchmarks the e-mail platforms publish from their own users' sending, the rules that apply to a sender, the price of a stamp, and what is on record for the businesses themselves.
What cold e-mail gets
Two companies that sell cold e-mail tools publish what their own users' cold e-mail got in 2025.
- Instantly reports an average reply rate of 3.43 percent across what its users sent from January 1 to December 18, 2025, with its top performers above 10 percent. Of all replies, 58 percent came from the first e-mail and 42 percent from the follow-ups.
- Hunter reports an average reply rate of 4.5 percent per sequence, from 31 million e-mails its users sent in 2025, and 3 percent for sales outreach alone. E-mails with no personalization averaged 3.6 percent, and e-mails with two custom details in the body 5.6 percent. Sending three messages instead of one raised the reply rate from 3.3 to 6.8 percent.
At Instantly's average, a thousand e-mails sent bring some 34 replies; at Hunter's, a thousand people written to bring some 45. A reply is not a sale: it can be a question, a "not now" or a "please stop". Both figures come from each platform's own users and what they sent, and the figures quoted here are for all of it, not for local businesses alone. Two findings are useful all the same: in Hunter's data a message with details written for its reader did better, and in both platforms' data the follow-ups brought a large share of the replies.

What the rules ask of an e-mail
The CAN-SPAM Act applies to commercial e-mail sent to businesses as much as to people. In the words of the Federal Trade Commission, "the law makes no exception for business-to-business email". Every commercial message must:
- not use false or misleading header information, or a deceptive subject line;
- identify itself as an advertisement;
- give the sender's valid physical postal address;
- tell the recipient how to opt out of future e-mail, and honor an opt-out within 10 business days.
Each separate e-mail that breaks the law can cost up to $53,088 in penalties, according to the FTC's guide.
The mailbox providers add their own rules. Google requires every sender to personal Gmail accounts (addresses ending in @gmail.com or @googlemail.com) to authenticate with SPF or DKIM and to keep the spam rate reported in its Postmaster Tools below 0.3 percent, and it advises staying below 0.1 percent. A bulk sender, more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail accounts, must also have SPF, DKIM and DMARC, and its marketing messages must support one-click unsubscribe. Microsoft asks much the same of domains that send more than 5,000 e-mails a day to its consumer Outlook.com addresses: since May 5, 2025, SPF and DKIM must pass and DMARC must be set (at least p=none), and mail that fails goes to the junk folder, with rejection announced for later.
None of the FTC's requirements is the recipient's consent in advance. Google and Microsoft, though, advise sending only to people who want your mail, and spam reports count against the sender: the address, the domain and the sending have to be set up with care, and every "no" honored.
What a postcard costs, and what is known about replies
The price of mailing a postcard is a fact. Under the Postal Service's price list effective October 4, 2026, a single-piece First-Class postcard costs $0.65 and a one-ounce letter with a stamp $0.82. Presorted First-Class postcards cost less: $0.453 each at the automation 5-digit price, for mailers who meet the presort and automation requirements. Printing and the design of the card come on top.
What a postcard gets back is harder to say from a primary source. Figures often quoted for direct mail come from the ANA Response Rate Report of the Association of National Advertisers; the report is behind a sign-in, and we did not read its figures, so we repeat no second-hand figures from it here. If you plan a campaign on a response rate for postcards, test it on a small batch of your own first.
What can be said: a postcard needs no e-mail address and passes through no mailbox provider's spam filter, and it arrives as a physical thing that someone at the business handles. It also costs at least the postage for every business, whether or not it replies.
How many local business listings have an e-mail address on record
This is where the data of this site helps. Of the 14,447,275 business listings in the United States, 5,082,522 have an e-mail address on record (35%), 11,585,561 a website (80%) and 12,962,420 a phone number (90%). It differs by kind of business:
| Kind | Listings | Website | Phone | E-mail address |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plumbing | 40,064 | 80% | 98% | 22% |
| HVAC services | 51,214 | 84% | >99% | 24% |
| Electricians | 35,906 | 78% | 99% | 22% |
| Restaurants | 790,967 | 79% | 88% | 37% |
| Dental clinics | 182,139 | 87% | 99% | 46% |
| Hair salons | 176,349 | 76% | 97% | 45% |
| Automotive repair | 239,719 | 69% | 96% | 48% |
| Roofing | 46,193 | 84% | 99% | 20% |
| Every listing, all kinds | 14,447,275 | 80% | 90% | 35% |
Listings in the open data, read when this page was made: release 2026-10-21.0, counted on .
An address in a listing is not an invitation to write. The most reliable place to find how a business wants to be contacted is its own website, and far more listings have a website on record than an e-mail address. For a business with no published e-mail address, a postcard or a letter is the way in that does not depend on one.
Choosing between them
For a seller to local businesses the numbers above point to a few plain rules.
- Start from the businesses, not the channel. Count the kind and the place you sell to, and look at what is on record for them. Where many have an e-mail address on record, e-mail can carry much of the work; where few do, a postcard can reach the rest.
- Write to each business as itself. Hunter's data rewards a message with details written for its reader, and Instantly credits its best campaigns to tight segments of recipients. A line taken from the business's own website is a reason to write that the reader can check.
- Follow up, and stop at a no. Hunter's figures favor three messages over one and show lower reply rates for sequences with three follow-ups or more; Instantly, which counts replies per e-mail sent, puts the best length at four to seven. A no ends it.
- Keep within the rules. Your name, an honest subject line, a plain statement that it is an offer, your postal address and a plain way to say no belong in every e-mail, and a sending domain set up as Google and Microsoft require.
- Count the cost per reply, not per piece. An e-mail costs next to nothing to send and a postcard at least its postage, so a postcard has to bring more replies per piece to be worth it. Test both on a small batch of your own market before you decide.
We are building a service that would do both for a seller: an e-mail to the address a business publishes on its own website, and a postcard by post, each in the seller's name and only after the seller approves it. It is not open yet, and no business is written to today; how it will work is set out step by step.
How this was counted
The counts of listings in this guide come from the places data of the Overture Maps Foundation, release 2026-10-21.0, counted on , by the same rules as every page of Buyerdex. A listing is a place in the open data in the fifty states or the District of Columbia that is not marked permanently closed, has a name and a kind of business, and has a confidence of at least 0.5 on the data's own scale. A business with three locations is three listings, a business the sources have not heard of is missing, and one that closed recently may still be in: a count here is not a census of companies. Each listing is filed under the narrowest kind the data knows for it, and a kind is counted together with the kinds under it, each listing once. “With a website” or “with an e-mail address” means the data holds one for the listing, not that we have checked that it still works. Figures from other publishers are theirs, as each source below gives them. The data, its sources and its limits.
Sources
- Cold Email Benchmark Report 2026, Instantly, updated January 12, 2026
- State of Email Outreach 2026 Report (The State of Cold Email), Hunter
- CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business, Federal Trade Commission
- Email sender guidelines, Google
- Strengthening Email Ecosystem: Outlook's New Requirements for High-Volume Senders, Microsoft, April 2, 2025, updated April 30, 2025
- Notice 123: Price List, United States Postal Service, effective October 4, 2026
- ANA Response Rate Report (2023 edition, published February 22, 2024), Association of National Advertisers